An Open Letter...
An Open Letter to Trump Voters
By Genevive Bevell
Dear Trump Voters,
Congratulations! Donald J. Trump is the 47th president of the United States of America, the second only to serve two terms non-consecutively. This is an extraordinary feat, of course. But what does this mean for the future of America?
Well, if you’ve followed Trump’s campaign, here’s what we see promises of:
The largest deportation of immigrants in American history
Higher tariffs on imported goods
The “ending” of the Ukraine and Palestine conflicts (predicted to be solved through more support to Israel and Russia)
Veto of an abortion ban if it comes to his desk (despite him appointing the three Supreme Court justices who helped revoke the protections codified under Roe v. Wade)
Cut federal funding for schools that teach critical race theory and gender studies and eliminate diversity, equity, and inclusion.
Ban on transgender women from competing in women’s sports
Deportation of international students who voice support for Palestine
Reversal of climate change prevention and regulation implemented under Biden
Many others
Now, I understand many of these issues you do not deem as important. The number one answer we saw from exit polls of counties that voted Republican when asked why they voted for Trump was the economy. We see this critique every day. “I just don’t want to pay $75 for four things at the grocery store,” laments the stay-at-home mother. “Gas is just far too high,” chides the baby boomer. “Make America Great Again,” the white male says.
But America has always been great for this last demographic. The stay-at-home mother and the baby boomer were unable to see how Kamala intended to protect them (protection of women’s reproductive rights and the strengthening of Medicare and Social Security being examples here.) But for white men, this country has always worked for them. Trump and his administration do not want to make America “great again.” They want to reinforce damaging and once humiliating laws and standards based on sexism, racism, homophobia, xenophobia, and a general sociopathic attitude toward the American people that promotes sole success for White men. Women make up 50.5% of the American population, documented immigrants and African Americans make up 13.7%, respectively, and Latinos and/or Hispanics make up 19.5% of the country. These are not small numbers. For reference, 13.7 percent of the population as of July 1st, 2023, is 45,883,341.
Kamala Harris got one major thing right, we cannot go back. We must move forward. Like it or not, these percentages are millions of people in this country who were promised life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness and are now in danger of losing their human right to this promise. America will never be “great again” in the way Trump wants, and I remind you that it is thanks to the likes of radical thinkers such as Martin Luther King Jr., Malcolm X, Marsha P. Johnson, Frederick Douglass, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Gloria Steinem, and many others who have stood up to discriminatory and hateful rhetoric and legislation in this country. They have made this country something changing—something always striving for greatness and equality while admitting and addressing continuing problems within our democracy.
White men who voted for Trump, this is specifically for you, listening ears on! You have played a major role in the potential devolution back to a deeply flawed system of governance that prides itself on the suffering of those who are different from you for the sake of your own flourishing. I want you to sit in that for a moment. Is that what you wanted? Truly and honestly with yourself, is that what you wanted? If the answer is yes, well, you are a white supremacist and a misogynist! If the answer is no, which I do truly hope it is, then you should reconsider why you voted for Trump. You may have it locked and loaded, “the economy!” you may be shouting at me right now. To your defense, I have not addressed why this is a ridiculous argument despite human and civil rights concerns.
So let’s talk about the economy, stupid.
The Economy:
The economy is currently in great standing–although Americans don’t feel it yet. Believe me, as a broke college student, I understand. But the truth of the matter is there is a delay in when an economic issue is realized, policy is implemented, when it affects measurements like the GDP, and when the American people feel the relief. This phenomenon is known as a lag. There are 4 types of “lags” when it comes to fiscal and monetary policy. Recognition, Decision, Implementation, and Response. All these lags make economic change, as we have unfortunately seen time and time again, a snail-like procedure.
Consider the Obama administration. When Obama entered office, he inherited an economy just recently hit by the Great Recession. Economists Alan Blinder and Mark Zandi found that “the recession would have lasted twice as long, job losses would have been twice as high, and the drop in GDP would have been more than three times worse–” had Obama not helped to implement his economic policies. When Trump entered office, he inherited this economy, and before he could implement any policy, we continued to experience lower unemployment, job growth, GDP growth, stock market improvement, and higher income. However, by the time Trump enacted his policy, we experienced less job growth, less income increase, and a stagnant GDP. In his defense, he continued to lower unemployment. But most economists will concede the economy was better before Trump.
Trump’s infamous 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act was intended to, self-explanatory, cut taxes and create jobs for all Americans. However, the data shows that this policy largely helped the richest people in the country rather than Americans who needed it. From an article written for the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities: “Households with incomes in the top 1 percent will receive an average tax cut of more than $60,000 in 2025, compared to an average tax cut of less than $500 for households in the bottom 60 percent, according to the Tax Policy Center (TPC). As a share of after-tax income, tax cuts at the top — for both households in the top 1 percent and the top 5 percent — are more than triple the total value of the tax cuts received for people with incomes in the bottom 60 percent” It was considered a success for the few and a failure for the many. The age-old story of capitalism. A story Trump is intimately familiar with. Then the Covid pandemic hit, and he handled it undeniably irresponsibly, both socially and economically. We felt the effects, the response if you will, from Trump’s economic policy, and we felt it harder because of the pandemic.
I ask you to picture my father, a self-employed business owner, who suffered under Trump’s economic response to the pandemic. His business was in shambles, and Trump offered no feasible solutions, leaving us going broke. Who knows, if the economy worked harder to protect people like my father–if we had democratic economic reform at that time, he could have possibly still been here today. My father passed shortly before the 2020 election and confided in me that for, if I recall correctly, the third time in his life, he would vote for a Democrat. My father a baby boomer Libertarian from the South. I tell you this story to convey my sympathy and understanding about the anger and frustration towards the handling of our economy, but I continue to urge you to see your anger is misplaced.
Many people have blamed Biden for our current economy. They are tragically right! The tragedy comes from the fact that our economy is, once again, in great standing. What they are really blaming Biden for is the economy he inherited from Trump. Coupled with recovering from an international pandemic and inheriting Trump’s shaky economy, Biden had a lot working against him. Yet he was able to pass the Inflation Reduction Act, which in the past two years has promoted growth in the sustainable energy and climate control industries. However, critics mention the delays that have occurred in around 40% of the projects the IRA proposed. Policy analyst Jack Conness addresses this perfectly:
“So you can't turn a billion-dollar factory on overnight. The scale of these projects is massive, but there's a contextual way I think about it. Let's say you're walking around your neighborhood, and you see a new home or an apartment building under construction. It feels like you can walk by it for weeks or months or even a year and see little progress being made, but eventually, it gets built, and we've built millions of houses over hundreds of years, and it's a pretty standardized process.”
So perhaps, what affected the Democratic party most in this election was the earlier mentioned response lag. The explanation behind why American people do not feel the effects of Biden’s economic policies, such as the Inflation Reduction Act, just yet. Nevertheless, we make policy in the hopes of improving the economy, one small push at a time. Where we often fail is agreeing on how to handle the issues presented to us. With the political divide between our two-party system perhaps stronger than ever, we find it hard to reach across the aisle and agree on, well, anything. Biden tried–to say what you rightfully want about him–but that much is true.
Intention is key, and it is not always clear. But I assure you, as a devout liberal, I want this economy fixed just as much as you. Kamala wanted this economy fixed. Trump, on the other hand, wants this economy to benefit him and his benefactors–Elon Musk, for one–because he owes them. He will bulldoze lower and middle-class families and individuals to continue to provide for the rich and powerful. Policies such as the TCAJ reflect Trump’s true intentions, and my wish is for you to see that. He is not interested in making you a millionaire, he is motivated solely by greed, as any good businessman is. But one of the main truisms that stood out to me from my high school politics and history education, bestowed on me by the wonderful minds of Ms. Sherry Norton and Ms. Julia Williams of Franklin High, was that greed has no place in politics. If we are to make true social and economic change, we must diverge from a leader who is determined to make it out of the White House a richer man, no matter who will suffer from his success.
Now, you may argue Trump’s economic policy has changed since then. He has seen where his policies could be improved to support larger groups of people and will do just that. Well, let’s see what Trump has to say. He plans to defund the IRA, make the TCAJ permanent, return to the #1 oil and gas producer in the world, impose higher tariffs on imported goods, and increase the “Commercial Space” sector. To put it in layman’s terms, he reverses any bipartisan progress he can, continues to decrease taxes for the 1%, increases fossil fuel emissions, which are contributing highly to the climate crisis, raises inflation, and invests in an industry not yet ready for debut. If this sounds swell to you, then get ready! You’re in for a treat!
When it was still possible for Harris to be the next president, she promised policies that would promote the nation’s economic growth, reaching the pockets of Americans and increasing asset ownership. Policies such as tax cuts for the middle class, down payment support of up to $25,000 for prospective homeowners, and outlawing new unjust price fixing from landlords–decrease the growing rent problem. These policies would’ve helped Americans of all kinds feel more grounded in the economy. They would’ve built upon the progress Biden inched towards, filling in the gaps where he lacked. Trump is going to run it into the ground.
I hope this reflection on the economy can help at least one Trump voter see that when you voted for Trump, you were not voting for the economy, America, you’re not even voting for yourself. You voted for rich men to get richer and the poor people to get poorer. All there is to do now is put pressure on our House and Senate to maintain the economy and avoid potential economic failings that could occur under Trump’s administration.
Women’s Rights:
One of the main things I have heard from Donald Trump voters is that they think Kamala Harris voters have “overreacted” to the news today. I would like to address this.
As a woman, it is impossible to detach myself from one of the major concerns with Trump’s second term. The protection and restoration of my reproductive rights. All women in my life have benefited from the protections provided by Roe v. Wade. Not only because it protects life-saving healthcare, but most importantly, it protects women’s autonomy over their own bodies. My grandmother, a single mother raising three kids with multiple jobs, could’ve terminated another pregnancy if it occurred, keeping her family out of poverty. My mother, a young woman not ready to have a child because of drug addiction, could choose that bringing a baby into the world was not the best choice for her or the baby. I, a female college student in 2024, however, am unable to get an abortion at any stage of pregnancy in the state of Tennessee unless it is for “an emergency.” No exception for if I was raped or if the baby was a product of incest. The reversal of Roe v. Wade was a historic and deeply frightening day for me and many other women. It seemed to us the beginning of a process attempting to strip away women’s recently gained autonomy over their lives. To undermine the process of many great feminist activists and policymakers. Something we learned from this election: it turned out to be exactly that.
Now, I have specifically addressed this letter to Trump supporters, so to you, I say directly you have put yourself on the wrong side of history. Supporting the man who aims to restrict the liberties of women and propel this country into a dangerous new landscape, where The Handmaid’s Tale does not seem so dystopian, is a failure on your part. He has no intention of vetoing an abortion ban, we all know that, both sides. You have failed your mothers, your grandmothers, your sisters, your daughters, your friends. People often use the aforementioned thought as an appeal to the pathos of Republicans, hoping to generate some basic empathy. However, I ask you to widen your scope if you wouldn’t mind. Consider the thousands of families who will have babies they will bond with–knowing the baby may die of a fatal birth defect before they turn 2–after the stress and grief of pregnancy and birth has already plagued the fragile mother. Consider the millions of women who will die during childbirth because the doctor fears going to jail for making the call to abort. Consider the unfortunate amount of women who will be told they must carry to term a product of something vile; rape and incest. Consider you.
To the college-age male, I ask you, what will you do if your contraception fails–which it can–and you now have to father a child? Your answer may have been one of two things. The first is, “I would accept that this is [insert Higher Power’s] plan for us and drop out of school and get a decent-paying job to provide for my family.” The second, “Leave that bitch, and I’m not paying child support!” These are direct quotes from college-age males at my university. (Your response may vary and fall somewhere in between; see this as a spectrum.) The first man, motivated by his faith, usually accepts responsibility and provides for the wife and child in a traditional patriarchal home. He then, later on in life, abuses his wife because he blames her for his lack of success, and the child lives in a broken home. Nuclear family fun. The second man is a misogynist, first and foremost, but also a prime example of how misogyny has shifted in the modern era, this man can be liberal or conservative, Republican or Democrat; this type of man makes up for a good amount of the spectrum. He is everywhere in our post-third-wave feminism culture.
We have denied men the ability to control our bodies, we have shown increasing participation in politics and community service, and we own homes, cars, and bank accounts, all on our own–if we want. The truth is the second man is scared of women and their having power and autonomy. So, he redirects that fear to hate. Another age-old lesson for white men–if you ignore and belittle the voice, you can’t hear it shouting. He has an inferiority complex. He desires to have the control and power he perceives the first man has but is unable to achieve it. So, he also takes out his feelings of inferiority, shame, and failure on women. But instead of using violence (usually), he puts women down by denying them love, compassion, care, and now autonomy. This man may be more overt about it, or he may conceal it well. We see, unfortunately, on the left side more so, a lot of men who pose in solidarity but do nothing with their position of privilege to enhance women’s lives. More often, we see how they manipulate and negatively affect us or hurt us by being a bystander and not standing up for us when it counts.
So, was this you? If it was, I have hope for you. I do. You have the power to change at any time. I urge you to consider how you can improve your relationship with women in your life and how that, in turn, will improve your life as a whole. We are not the enemy. We do not want superiority, we want equality. We want you to fight for our reproductive rights, to show up when we need you most–I would argue that if this support was shown in large numbers, many women would then go on to advocate for certain men’s issues. I know I am concerned about the rise in male loneliness and male suicide rates. But what I also recognize is these are results of toxic masculinity. Ideas such as “boys don’t cry” and “be a man.” Whatever the latter means. However, it is my belief that if we bridged the gender gap; if men were more open and compassionate with women, if we engaged in intellectual and emotional dialogue about life, love, empathy, and our beliefs; if men used their privilege to speak up for us if they made efforts to make us feel safe; if men supported women in their career paths if they openly acknowledged our work; we could work together to create a more beneficial culture for everyone. A culture of openness towards one another and compassion for others. We could build a nation that follows through on the promise of liberty and justice for all.
I believe in this vision, still, even after today’s results. I believe in an America where a woman who has worked in all three branches of government can win the presidency against a man who is a convicted felon. I believe there is a world where we can see past archaic gender roles and ideologies and move forward into a better future for all humans. It starts with reinstating reproductive freedom. It starts with you.
A Danger to Democracy:
My encouragement for you to engage in more grassroots efforts to help women–making changes to your own life to bring about liberty and justice for all is rooted in my desire to see democracy prosper. The idea of the good of the people. I wish to see Democrats and Republicans collaborating and compromising on how to appease the people. After all, that is the best we can hope for our country–the ideal we aspire to. One thing I know for certain, Donald Trump has no desire to bridge the gap between Americans. He has every intention of continuing to push far-right politics to an extent bordering on fascism.
Many of you are in denial over this. Understandably so–who would vote for a fascist? But the truth remains. Dr. Brian Hughes for The Guardian says:
“I think it’s important to remember that fascism isn’t a binary. Fascism is a process,” said Hughes in an interview with the Guardian. “Since the very beginning of the Trump campaign in 2015, there’s been a lot of denialism and a lot of whistling past the graveyard, but the symptoms keep adding up.”
In fact, many of his tactics mirror those of Hitler or Mussolini. These are not extreme comparisons. They are based on actual analysis of his political moves and rhetoric. Hitler’s religious views are varied and contended, but he was raised Catholic. Biographer of Hitler, John Willard Tolard, offers this potential insight into Hitler’s thinking, "[He] carried within him [Catholic] teaching that the Jew was the killer of God. The [genocide], therefore, could be done without a twinge of conscience since he was merely acting as the avenging hand of God…” This is a haunting potential view into Hitler’s psyche. It is important to note he did not remain Christian, nor was he ever that devout. It rather highlights the use of God to explain away his horrific actions as fate. Just last night, in his victory speech, Trump claimed that “God spared my life for a reason, and that reason was to save our country and restore America to greatness.” Be careful with your words, Trump! Someone might think you believe that God wants you to kill innocent people at the border in Ukraine or Palestine! They may even think you believe in the Divine right to rule, which would make you an absolutist! Which, obviously, has no place in a democracy. Right…? Now, with this context and comparison, we’ve given him a second term. So what now?
I do not think Donald Trump can overthrow our democracy. However, I could be gravely underestimating him. Yet, let’s operate within the hypothetical that he does not have said ability. Well, we will experience a very far-right four years, a terrible four years of economic floundering, and then maybe, just maybe, in 2028, we will see how far-right policy is failing us and vote Democratic. Or, what if I am underestimating him and Trump announces he’s going to try for a third term? He can’t, but we know well that he is above the law. At least, he believes so. I would, too if I was found guilty on 34 felony counts and then 6 months later became the President again. What if this devolves into complete control of the Supreme Court? Control in the Senate and House? A one-party state. It’s a pretty big what-if, I understand. To some, it may seem imaginable. But to many political analysts, the trends align, and the comparisons are there. You may still disagree, and that is fine. But as the idiom says, follow the money and see where it goes.
Where Democrats Failed, Radicalism in the New Right, and What’s Next?
You may be thinking to yourself, “Well, if Trump is a fascist, does that mean we just have to accept a democratic candidate?” NO! Literally, not at all. For too long, Trump has been the monolith of the Republican party, but he does not have to be. Part of the concern over him being something of a celebrity when he initially entered office was that his personality would be too big for a president, that he would divide the American people, and, well, he did just that. Until he didn’t need to anymore. Our political culture is teetering on absurd. With the insurrection on January 6th, Trump’s two assassination attempts, Kamala Harris doing the “Apple” dance on TikTok (“Apple” is a song on Charli XCX’s album brat. The singer was considered a big endorsement for Harris, especially among women and gay Americans.) No matter what “side” you are on, I hope that much is evident.
Politics feels a bit like a joke. This is mainly because our Democratic and leftist politicians are trying to “What up, my fellow teens?” their way into getting young people to vote and hopefully vote for them. However, this is not what most broadly appeals to all Americans. As of data from 2022, when the U.S. census estimated a total of 333.3 million people nationwide, people aged 20-24 made up 6.8% of the population. These numbers will likely increase by 2024, however, for as much funding that went into social media campaigning and the appearances of Gen Z cultural icons, it does not seem to be a worthy payday. This is not to say that she did not appeal to more than just the young voter demographic but rather to highlight a flaw in the campaign.
On the other side, alternatively, Trump was smart about his chips on the board. He had the white male Republican vote in the bag, the 65 and upvote was predicted to sway in his favor, certain women riddled with internalized misogyny would vote for him, and for some reason beyond my cultural understanding, he even got votes from Black and Latino men and the LGBTQ+ community. He was able to unite a large group of American people. Why? Because he preached a universal and strong message. Hate.
Yes, because no matter who you are, Trump has given you someone to hate, and in our cynical, loveless society, hate slowly replaces love as the supreme virtue. The paradox ensues that Trump still makes racist remarks toward Latino people and Black people. He says disparaging things about transgender people and gay people. But everyone is swept up in this vortex of spewing hate, they don’t even know where they’re aiming. This is what he wants. Mass hysteria. His desire for chaos is fueled by right-wing conspiracy theorists, a controversial billionaire who owns one of the most popular social media platforms, and toxic misogynists who encourage the attitude of women being lesser than men. We watch or read these interactions in another spectrum of reactions ranging from, “It’s like a car crash, I just can’t look away” to “Yeah! He totally owned those liberals!” I beg you to not fall victim to it. To be of sound mind and heart. Ignore the noise. Find the way back to the message of love. Both parties, everybody, if we learn to let love guide us, to block out the misinformation and hateful messages, we can create a better America too, once again, liberty and justice for ALL.
This is a daunting task, I understand, and I know you may feel powerless in the grand scheme of it all. But I reiterate that change begins with you. If you identify as a Republican, it is your party–help reshape it. Vote for sane, qualified candidates who uphold the values of democracy in Republican primaries and caucuses. Participate in your democracy instead of blindly listening to Trump falsely report on it. Lead your life with love, and watch how the country will prosper.
My hope is that there is a near future where we reach moderation. Where a Democrat feels comfortable voting Republican if they see fit, and a Republican can vote Democrat if they see fit. Where we do not have extremist candidates spewing dangerous fascist rhetoric. The greatest news from this election is that not a single American has to vote for Trump again. After this term–and make no mistake, work to protect our democracy must still occur during the term–we can begin working towards a better, more united States.
We The People
I, regretfully, do not have the bandwidth to speak in depth on more issues within this work—there are truly many more. But I hope to anyone reading this, Trump supporter or not, that you have gained a better understanding of our country in one way or another. That you feel more equipped to vote in 2028. That you understand the issues facing our country and how pressing they truly are. We are facing a potential threat to our democracy. I do not say that to fear-mongers like Trump would. However, it is reasonable to be scared, especially as a woman or any marginalized community in our country. I also understand the fear that may come with attempting to dismantle systems that put people down. I do not deny you this fear. Whether it be the fear of consistency or change. However, I sincerely urge you to use this fear as motivation. Channel all that overwhelming energy into action. Fear often comes when one experiences a lack or loss of power. So I remind you, my fellow Americans of all origins and identities, you have the power.
It’s a long road from here. But we will pick each other up, we will hold our politicians accountable, we will be active participants in our community and democracy, and we will make the change. But we can only do it together. So, dear Trump voters, I hold you accountable for your implication in what occurred today. I am deeply saddened by these results and, too, like many others, felt discouraged this morning. But I extend this olive branch to you. If you choose to deny it, that is your American right to choose. I just ask that you give me the same right to my body.
Sincerely,
Genevive Bevell
Comments
Post a Comment