The Oscars and White People
Oh, the Oscars. One of my personal favourite forms of bread and circus. A time when the Hollywood elite come together to celebrate the nominees for the most prestigious award in cinema. I mean, what's not to love about well-groomed celebrities making tongue-in-cheek references to their own work and Conan O'Brien! On a sincere note, it is also a time to celebrate all the wonderful, talented artists we have lost as well. The touching tributes to Rob Reiner, Diane Keaton, and Robert Redford stand out from this year. "Buddy, what fun we had storming the castle," Billy Crystal said in memorial of friend and colleague, Reiner.
This year was special. This year was defined by what seemed to be a budget of $1,000 and outrageously strange cutoffs. Well, that, and all the buzz leading up to the events of the night. I do not know a single person not invested in the tight race of Best Actor, Best Director, and Best Picture. Michael B. Jordan versus Timothee Chalamet. Ryan Coogler versus Paul Thomas Anderson. Sinners versus One Battle After Another. It is a race that felt undeniably loaded, greatly due to--excuse the pun--the races of each artist. Sometimes you watch the Oscars and see a clear winner. Sometimes you get a year of movies so good, you are happy with whoever wins. Always, there are politics involved.
Before I go any further, I must make it known to anyone who has not heard me scream it from the rooftops, that I am a staunch supporter of Sinners. That movie had the emotional impact on me that only Nicole Kidman could describe. "That indescribable feeling we get, when the lights begin to dim, and we go somewhere we've never been before. Not just entertained but somehow reborn." Exactly. It was about a quarter of the way through the movie when I realized it was the movie of the year for me. I remember the exact moment. It was right after Smoke and Stack buy the property to start their juke joint. The man they purchase it from claims with a hearty laugh that the Klan is no longer around. Immediately after that statement, it cuts to a little, white church with a pointy roof. Ooh... I get chills just recalling it. Ryan Coogler is a cinematic genius.
But I also recall thinking to myself, "This won't win any awards and that sucks." I had so little faith in the academy to recognize real, impactful art that I had given up hope before the race even started. Once nominations were rolling in and I saw Sinners on the list, I started to get filled with that dangerous little flicker of hope. Not only because it was on the list, but because it became the most nominated film in Oscars history, surpassing Titanic and La La Land. A beyond huge accomplishment within itself. What was dampening my flicker of hope was one hopeful, young, and hubristic Chalamet and one veteran, talented, multiple-time nominee Anderson. These were, of course to the White film bro, the underdog candidates. The ones to root for. Naturally, because they see themselves reflected in these men. They're either "in the pursuit of greatness" or not acknowledged for their greatness. Sure... I can see how the White man will most directly see himself reflected in these people.
But I felt most reflected and seen by Coogler, Jordan, and all the cast and crew involved in Sinners who crafted a beautiful, heartbreaking tale about the price of assimilation and the sacrifices made to survive. To me, the Black man who made a horror movie (an unappreciated genre at the awards show before this year) was the underdog, the one to celebrate. Which was difficult, because he walks a tightrope--not necessarily a veteran and certainly not a newcomer. He wasn't boastful about the work and yet was not overly humble to a degree that makes everyone uncomfortable. I was worried it'd be very easy to ignore Sinners and Coogler's accomplishments with the delusions of grandeur hullabaloo happening for White men.
Surely enough, an interesting, revealing thing happened that night. 4 oscars were given to Sinners for Original Screenplay, Cinematography, Best Actor, and Best Original Score. While One Battle After Another took home 6: Adapted Screenplay, the new Best Casting, Best Editing, Best Supporting Actor (Sean Penn), Best Director, and Best Picture. Let's break down the significance of which awards were given to whom. The Screenplay awards were the most balanced of the night, with each of these movies taking home in their own categories. Two historic awards occured for each movie: the inaugural Casting award went to OBAA while Sinners' cinematographer, Autumn Durald Arkapaw, was the first woman of colour to win in that category. They both took home Actor wins in Jordan and Penn. Sinners also earned Ludwig Göransson his third Oscar. With the oddly even split of awards, I was beginning to wonder if that's how the best picture and director awards would go as well. But no, they both went to OBAA.
Now, I have heard the critique that the buffoonish, out of place White guy trying too hard archetype is exactly the effect Anderson intended and, quite frankly, that doesn't cut it for me. And also, like... duh. I'm sure that it is about Anderson's own feelings of inadequacy in changing the world, about not being able to leave a better world for his daughter, about not understanding how to make her world better. These are all great themes, it's a great movie, I don't deny that. But for the Academy to look at a film that is quite literally about Black revolution and the power to change your life for better or worse, about making action and surviving, and compare it to a tale of the White man's inability to participate in that and feel that the latter deserves both of the most important awards of the night is very telling to me. To note: the Academy is 35% women and 22% from underrepresented minority communities. If that proves telling to you.
If this Oscars accomplished nothing else, it reminded me how much we love to profit off of Black culture and award White men and how the mainstream consumer as well as artistic critics are more comfortable viewing stories of historically Black revolution through a White man's lens. I'm not saying it's intentional or conscious but we have learned all of history through the lens of the White man. History is told by the oppressor. It is an inherent familiarity to see Leonardo DiCaprio bumbling his way through an otherwise tight and intense narrative of Black women doing all the work than it is for the voting body to see people of colour organizing under their noses to have their own joy, their own revolution.
My whole thesis about profiting off Black culture as a Hollywood norm was proven by the aforementioned Chalamet, who was a sort of side show to the main attraction for me, who seemed to undergo a whole style and personality transplant on this press tour. He was on a campaign to win and wanted to present as a winner. Using, undeniably, Black culture to do so. It appeared, to me, as a sleazy, capitalist marketing ploy. It was a great satisfaction watching him lose that Oscar to Jordan. It felt like the bit of justice needed from Sinners losing out on Director and Picture.
TTYL,
too woke friend

The academy is kinda funny to me because I feel like there's a lot more weight put on it for films specifically, but I don't really see that gravity in other equivalents. I know so many musicians who don't care about the Grammys (although the amount of these people is slowly falling down), and I definitely don't know an actor or theatre person who even watches the Tonys, and when I ask, I feel like most people just answer with something along the lines of "it's a dumb game show that's scripted and doesn't mean anything idgaf" but then the Oscars pull up and, especially for anyone I know in film, they show all the way up. I've always wondered what it was about the Oscars that give them such mass appeal as compared to the other big award shows. Who knows? I don't.
ReplyDeleteAnyways, my favorite part of the essay was when you said "I had so little faith in the academy to recognize real" and I thought that was the end of the sentence and I thought that was a great phrase and in my head I was like "yeah talk that talk"